The exterior of a typical modern leaky building often belies the
damage within. It only takes a few judicial digs with a crowbar to
reveal the true extent of mouldy horror.
That soggy mess might as well be piles of wet $20 notes. Like a
heritage building in need of renovation, what is hidden below the
surface of a leaky building can be a devastating shock to the
owner.
Official estimates put the number of leaky buildings dating from
1992 onwards certainly in the tens of thousands and possible as
many as 90,000. The true extent may be even higher. What's clear is
they will cost billions to fix.
In each case, an expert quantity surveyor (QS) is a huge asset
in ensuring any rescue mission is costed correctly from the start.
A leaky building owner often feels helpless and their anguish is
compounded if the cost of repairs balloons unexpectedly.
Because it is such a big financial commitment to go through a
dispute resolution process such as adjudication, building owners
need to weigh up those likely costs of the process versus selling
the building as it is, with appropriate disclosures.
A QS will help provide sound cost benefit analysis to aid the
decision.
Now that their skills are being more widely recognised, QS
professionals are becoming more involved in New Zealand's
weathertight remediation process. Specialised consultants provide
cost estimation retrospective and back-costing analysis, and expert
quantum evidence during a dispute resolution process.
A QS who specialises in this field will work alongside the
building surveyor to develop a comprehensive cost estimate which
details the items identified in the repair recommendations. A good
QS is aware of the myriad unknowns which are likely to read their
ugly head.
No matter the size of the project, it is critical for all
parties to know the costs of what is involved, and the potential
pitfalls and benefits of all the options. Only then can a
well-informed decision be made to proceed or not.
If a leaky building owner decides to have the problem fixed, it
is important a QS is involved throughout the process. A good QS is
indispensible, helping to weigh up options and provide lateral
solutions to problems along the way, and amending the project
budget accordingly. If expenditure is to be increased in one area,
savings need to be made elsewhere. For leaky building projects, a
QS provides a breakdown of all labour and material costs and
ongoing financial management of cists during the repair process to
ensure payment claims are fair and reasonable.
A true professional should help make the process as stress-free
as possible. People who are unfortunate enough to own a leaky
building should select a project team which has their best
interests at heart.
It is almost inevitable that a leaky building project will be an
emotional rollercoaster for the owner. An expert QS should show
empathy along the way, rather than simply sending through a series
of invoices.
In most leaky building situations, the first step should be
obtaining legal advice which establishes whether the owner has a
legal remedy. Next, a building surveyor should thoroughly assess
the state of the building - a QS should come on boards during the
building surveyor's preliminary specialised area of the profession,
with expert knowledge required to deal with mould, fungi, and
different types of timber, and to collect evidence and data
necessary to move forward to some sort of dispute resolution
process.
Usually the biggest unknown is how much timber damage and decay
there is going to be. Often, a closer look reveals other examples
of poor workmanship around structure, drainage or fire ratings,
which can be a surprise. Builders, building surveyors and the QS
can work together during this stage to fully quantify the extent of
the damage.
Leaky buildings present many opportunities for the building
industry and quantity surveyors to work together. Rather than an
'us and them' situation, a close alliance should be promoted.
Being involved from start to finish is the optimum way a QS can
guide an owner through the leaky building minefield, and help keep
the lid on costs.
download pdf of this article